Let me be straight with you—if you’ve landed here, you’re probably annoyed.
You typed the SSH command, hit Enter, and boom:

Permission denied (publickey,gssapi-with-mic,password)

Yeah. That one.

I’ve seen this error more times than I can count, and honestly, it still gets me sometimes. The good news? It’s almost never “mysterious.” It’s just SSH being picky… and Google Compute Engine being a little too clever for its own good.

So let’s slow down and talk through this like real humans.

First Things First: What This Error Actually Means

Here’s the thing—this error isn’t saying your server is broken.
It’s saying:

That’s it. No drama. Just a locked door.

If you’re using a Debian or CentOS image on Google Compute Engine, this almost always comes down to SSH keys, usernames, or metadata not lining up.

And yes, one tiny mismatch is enough to shut everything down.

The Usual Suspects (And Yep, I’ve Made These Mistakes Too)

1. Your SSH Key Isn’t Loaded (or Doesn’t Exist)

Real talk—this is the most common one.

If you’ve never used gcutil ssh before, there’s a good chance you don’t even have the Google Compute Engine SSH key yet. No key, no entry, no access.

Or maybe the key exists… but your SSH agent isn’t running.
Or SSH is looking at the wrong key.

SSH doesn’t guess. It shrugs and says “no.”

2. Your Key Doesn’t Match What’s on the Server

Even if you do have a key, it still has to match what’s inside:

~/.ssh/authorized_keys

If the public key in metadata doesn’t match your local private key exactly, that’s a hard stop. Think of it like having the right lock but the wrong cut.

Close doesn’t count.

3. You’re Logging in as the Wrong User (Yep, This Happens a Lot)

Look—Google Compute Engine does not let you log in as root by default. Period. End of story.

So if you’re trying something like:

ssh root@your-vm

…it’s not failing randomly. It’s doing exactly what it’s supposed to do.

Also, if the username in your SSH metadata doesn’t exist on the VM yet, SSH won’t magically create it. That part happens separately.

How Google Compute Engine Handles SSH (The Part Nobody Explains Well)

Here’s the behind-the-scenes magic most people don’t realize is happening.

On standard Debian and CentOS images, there’s a background script running every minute. It does a few important things:

  • Pulls SSH keys from project or instance metadata

  • Creates Linux user accounts automatically

  • Adds keys to authorized_keys

  • Grants sudo access

But—and this is a big but—the SSH key must be formatted like this:

username:ssh-rsa AAAA...

Wrong format? Script ignores it.
Script ignores it? No user.
No user? Permission denied.

Simple chain reaction.

When SSH Is Completely Dead (Here’s Your Lifeline)

If SSH won’t let you in at all, don’t panic. You still have one solid option.

Check the serial port logs:

gcutil getserialportoutput

This is clutch. You can actually see:

  • Whether the SSH key script ran

  • If metadata was read correctly

  • If account creation failed

I’ve fixed more “unreachable” VMs using serial output than I care to admit.

What gcutil ssh Really Does (And Why It Usually Just Works)

Here’s why gcutil ssh feels almost magical when manual SSH doesn’t.

It:

  1. Looks for a key at ~/.ssh/google_compute_engine

  2. Creates one if it doesn’t exist

  3. Checks project metadata for your public key

  4. Adds it if missing

  5. Waits for the VM to catch up

  6. Logs you in using the right username and key

So yeah—when in doubt, use it. It removes a lot of human error.

Common Failures (And How to Fix Them Without Losing Your Mind)

SSH Uses the Wrong Key

Fix:
Explicitly tell SSH which key to use:

ssh -i ~/.ssh/google_compute_engine username@VM_IP

You Never Generated a Key

Fix:
Run:

ssh-keygen

Then add the .pub file to SSH metadata.

Username Doesn’t Match

Fix:
Use:

ssh -l correct_username VM_IP

Metadata usernames matter. A lot.

You Broke the Metadata Script

Fix:
If system scripts were modified, restore defaults—or honestly, recreate the VM using a clean image. Sometimes that’s faster and safer.

Hard-Earned Advice (Learn From My Mistakes)

  • Use gcutil ssh at least once per VM

  • Don’t mess with SSH system scripts unless you really know why

  • Keep usernames consistent

  • Always double-check metadata

  • Save your SSH keys somewhere safe

Trust me—future you will thank you.

Final Thoughts

That “Permission denied (publickey,gssapi-with-mic,password)” error feels brutal, but it’s not personal. It’s just SSH being exact and Google Compute Engine enforcing its rules.

Once you understand how keys, metadata, and users connect, this stops being a nightmare and starts being… manageable.

Also Read:  How2Invest